Serious Cash Infusion For Sirius XM
With the financial sector on a roller coaster ride, concerns over credit debt and liquidity have impacted companies across the board regardless of sector. While the Federal Government has stepped in to bail out AIG, it could represent the latest of “lines in the sand” drawn to try to avert a crisis, that may or may not work. Concerns over Washington Mutual, Wachovia and others still loom, so the roller coaster ride is not over quite yet.
Meanwhile, in the midst of all of this we have Sirius XM Radio that has $300 million in converts in February, and then additional debt coming later in 2009. In total, the company would like to finance about $1 billion in debt. In current markets that represents challenges for Sirius XM radio. While they may have some offers, they are likely at rates that the company would rather not have.
So what viable solutions are available?
Currently Sirius XM Radio has about 19,000,000 subscribers. The company, at this point, should give consideration to any and all avenues to generate enough cash from that subscriber base to put themselves in a position to either better negotiate with lenders, or better yet pay down that debt.
BEST OF
As we are all aware, the “Best Of” programming will be available on October 5th. This programming offers the ability for current Sirius subscribers to access some additional programming from the XM service, and XM subscribers to receive Sirius programming. The charge for this premium service is $4.99 per month.
Let’s assume that 10% of the subscriber base thinks that “Best Of” is a great idea. Why not offer a pre-launch of “Best Of” right away at a discounted rate in exchange for a one year prepayment. The “Best Of” will cost subscriber $60 per year if they pay monthly. Pre-Launch it for $40 for one year, and start collecting the money. The offer will be good only until October 31st. With 1,900,000 subscribers (only 10% of the existing subscriber base) paying $40 each up front, it would instantly deliver $76,000,000 into the coffers of the company.
PREPAYMENT BONUS
Start a campaign titled something like “Add A Year For Your Ear”. Sirius XM Radio currently enjoys a subscriber pool where over 20% of the base is on a 1 year or higher plan. Let those loyal subscribers get a good deal, and bring cash into the company. One year of the base service costs $155. The company should take advantage of the fact that their subscribers like to prepay, and further that people want a good deal in these trying economic times. Let this group of subscribers add a year to their existing plan for $100. This loyal group of about 3,800,000 subscribers would infuse the company with an additional $380,000,000. In addition, some that currently do not prepay may be enticed to step up to the plate themselves. If getting a good deal encouraged 500,000 additional subscriber to prepay, that would add another $50,000,000 to the mix.
FAMILY PLAN
A second subscription runs $6.99 per month. Both Sirius and XM have marketed this for years, and recently the marketing efforts have been stepped up. Why not sweeten the deal during this special period. Add a year on a second subscription, and get it for $60 instead of the normal $84. If 500,000 new family plan subscriptions were added that normally would not have, the added revenue would be another $30,000,000.
Such programs are not free from dangers. Selling the subscription at a lower price devalues the product. You have to be careful with how you do this. It is for this reason that the program should run for a very limited time and for a very specific reason. Right now there is a natural reason in the announcement of the merged company programming finally being launched on October 5th. This program should also be limited to October 31st.
Another impact would be in the company financials. All prepayments are deferred revenue and count as a liability on the financial statements. The silver lining is that the company “pays off” that liability by delivering the very service that they already deliver anyway. As the service is delivered to the prepay customers, the deferred revenue column will decrease.
Because the company is getting revenue up front, it will also impact future cash flow. If the consumer has already paid, they will not be paying in future months. For this reason, the company needs to do this in a disciplined manner so as not to throw the financials and cash flows out of whack going forward.
The goal here is to increase the cash position to an extent where Sirius XM Radio is no longer at the mercy of the financial institutions, and can negotiate from a position of strength. For this program to succeed, it is important that it be mass marketed. That will mean costs, but the goal is to get at least another $300,000,000 or more into the coffers without additional debt.
It is currently a situation of taking a whack on the chin in the way of high interest rates on borrowed money OR creating a bit of unsettlement in the financial statements for a quarter or two. Personally I believe that the company has avenues to explore that buy not only time, but negotiating power as well. At this point, such a solution is more palatable than the debt overhang, and the perception that comes with it. Additionally, the marketing efforts will offer longer term benefits as the company goes into the all important fourth quarter.
While this is a napkin sketch overview, Cash Is King. Get some cash into the company, and gain leverage.
Position: Long SIRI
Tyler, check out crfceo’s latest post on Satwaves: “S&P Maintains Buy on SIRI Expects ‘Decisive Steps’ Soon”
Hey Tyler….do you think in light of the demise of Lehman and stock beat down of AIG…that the SEC will FINALLY….FINALLY do something about the RAMPANT NAKED SHORTING???
I wonder why NO ONE on CNBC is talking about this…and it BOGGLES the mind. Not saying that Lehman, and AIG are innocent….far from it….BUT the RELENTLESS BEAT DOWN of stocks in every sector by NAKED short selling is OUT OF CONTROL….and a MAJOR contributor in the overall PANIC in the market.
WHEN will the SEC stop this? When will CNBC friggin REPORT ABOUT it with more than a passing comment.
I mean I sit there and watch the CNBC knuckle heads talking today like it financial armageddon was going on(and it was)….and yet they DONT EVEN FRIGGIN MENTION how MUCH naked shorting is giving shorts the FREEDOM to KILL COMPANIES.
They are out of control and totally unchecked, and something has to be done. The shorts should NOT have an edge over the longs. Naked shorting should be stopped immediately. And in this economic environment, it should be made CRIMINAL if not TREASONOUS to naked short.
What they are doing is fanning the flames of panic by DESTROYING companies that may have survived if the balance between shorts and longs were on a level playing field.
I wrote this earlier in the day before reading your column.
I am not a subscriber to Sirius XM, as I only drive once a week, but I do listen to the service provided from my Dish Network. My friends have XM and Sirius. When my driving conditions change, I’ll reconsider. I like many others are down huge $$$ by holding onto the stock, and debt refinancing issues, continue to bring the stock price down.
If Sirius XM needs $300M by February, why not ask the subscribers to reconsider the annual subscription option. In a plain honest letter explain the benefits and rewards that can be mutually achieved by both parties. I prepay my auto insurance, and also save a few dollars. If 3 to 10% of current subscribers opted for this plan, better debt refinancing can be achieved.
$ 75M / $150 = 500k subscribers = 2.5% – less money to borrow
$142M / $150 = 950k subscribers = 5% – better conditions.
$300M / $150 = 2M subscribers = 10% – a dream come true
Also let’s not forget additional revenue generated by Best of Both Programming.
I have SIRIUS and plan on buying XM, with the best of SIRI package. I like the new portable. But I can’t do anything until October 6. I wanted to make the 4th quarter. But you can’t subscribe until you have a radio. Hope many others do the same. I think this may be the best way to help the debt situtation. That, from what I have read, is the cause of the ‘naked shorts’.
I mentioned naked shorting with the banks, because even tho the SEC didn’t care about the naked shorting of stocks like SIrius…perhaps they’ll wake up and STOP this practice illegal now that the entire financial sector is collapsing in a large part due to the very same naked shorting.
I think you’re right Tyler….I hope Mel is listening, because from what he said at that breakfast meeting today…he was pretty brutally honest that the environment “sucks” for refinancing.
Heres the article with quotes from Mel:
Not that this will shock anyone, but with Wall St. falling off the high wire, this is unlikely to be a a period of big time dealmaking. Speaking at a breakfast sponsored by Portfolio, media bigs Mel Karmazin, Jeff Zucker and Steve Rattner (Quadrangle), agreed that a slow period for deals will only get slower. Said Rattner: “It’s been an incredibly slow year for the media M&A landscape and I think what’s happened in the last few days is simply going to exacerbate that. Big deals today are not going to happen. They’re simply not going to happen.” Karmazin—who has watched shares of Sirius (NasdaqGS: SIRI – News) slip below $1 since his merger with XM (Nasdaq: XMSR – News)—didn’t predict a total deal freeze, but said any financing would come at a steep price (that’s been the story for awhile, even before all the latest).
The panel moderator, Portfolio’s Joanne Lipman, tried prodding the trio into predicting when deals would come back, but despite several attempts, they never took the bait. Karmazin said it would happen when sellers fully ratcheted down their price expectations.
tyler, I had the same idea, but I had not yet written it down on a napkin, or fully expanded upon it as you have done…
think it could work, and considering no real announcement yet of the merger, that could be the “reason” for the special, i.e., to celebrate the merger!
Thank you Tyler. Good ideas. I would like to add one piece to it. Not that the investors have not already done enough, but I would suggest that Mel Send a letter to all shareholders who also subscribe already to Sirus or XM, and make this offer to them personally. I’m not sure what number this represents. Also, I don’t care to listen to Howard Stern, but would like to get all talk radio and sports together on one portable radio that can plug into my car. That puts me on hold for the moment for additional purchases of radios. However, I would pre-pay if that would help. I am a 12.95 XM subscriber now and because I pre-pay 3 months at a time, it reduces my pmt to approx $35. Thanks again.
By t he way, I am an XM subscriber because I own a Honda, but I own 25,000 SIRI shares. Averaged down from 6.79 to the last purchase at .88. Holding my breath but getting deeper and deeper and it HURTS.
great ideas tyler,send this article to mel!
Maybe they need to offer a tiered approach to pre-pay. A combination of all could be a windfall if promoted right.
genius
Hey Tyler , Can you do an Investigated piece on SIRI -Invester/Stock holders – myself and wife started buying and trading siri shares 4 years ago,and my 2005 dodge has siri and her new GM has XM ,, we both love the radios and service, its a company that has potential to run if given half the chance,,but serious what do you think of the implications of Bankrupcy or going private would to all those SUB/STOCKHOLDERS–if I lost anything -content ,sub fees or share value-I’m gone looking for a better service–
This article shows why you write a blog and not run a real company. You have zero understanding of revenue streams involved in this merged company.
Chad….
Rather than come in and throw darts, why not add your thoughts? Instead we get insults with no material; at all.
You say I have “zero understanding of revenue streams of this compnay”
Please outline what exactly you are saying.
Revenue streams include subscription revenue, ad revenue, activation revenue, deferred revenue from prepays, etc.
The article clearly outlines that there are advantages and disadvantages to wha I am proposing. There is a need to weigh the benefit of this cash infusion vs. the long short/long term impact on the financials.
I, as wll as readers would love to hear your thought. Why not share them.
Further, you have no idea what I run or don’t run. Why stoop to insults and speculation about me? Talk about the company. Insults accomplish little, and add no real value to anything except perhaps your ego. The very fact that you took the time to make your initial comment is telling. Let’s turn over a new leaf here and see a comment that contributes to everyones understanding. If you think I have something wrong in what I wrote spell it out.
Bear in mind that this is an article and not an in-depth look at all of the details. It gives a big picture viewpoint while cautioning about potential impacts.
We look forward to hearing a thoughtful reply with insight.
No shit, who the hell are you, Chad? Say something meaningful instead of just being a dick.
Is it at all possible for Sirius XM to rework the contracts to be back-loaded. This way Sirius pays more, but less now and a more later on? I think it would make sense considering that all the involved parties run the risk of getting nothing at all.
LOL, I thought of this right after Sirius announced their horrendous convert offering. Even though Mel says he was afraid the NAB would get an injunction, the truth is he just wanted to get it done and didn’t realize the consequences could be so dire. Do we really think some court would be willing to undo, even temporarily, what it took the DOJ and FCC to approve after a year and half long investigation?
In any event, NOT only should Mel and Co. have approached their huge subscriber base – the one he is constantly bragging about, they should also have approached existing shareholders. Think about it: had he given ALL shareholders first dibs on the convert offering, the excitement of merger approval could easily have driven a successful offering within days. It’s true he can still do that but I doubt Sirius management is about to listen to us unsophisticated investors any time soon.
Chad, take your 2 cent to lehman bros.
DO YOU HAVE A BETTER IDEA A-HOLE
Tyler, Thank you for a great idea. I’m one of the original 300 who sign up with siri and i have 4 membership. I will purchase my 5 unit today for a Gulf vet and pay his 1 year of services to help out GR8 Job.