An accurate analogy of what Echostar is doing
Three things to keep in mind, #1 Echostar has not accumulated nearly 51% of SiriusXM debt (necessary)therefore it cannot take control,
#2 Echostar would need Sirius to default on the Feb debt for the courts to entertain their interst.
#3 If on the other hand Sirius pays the Feb debt due of $174 million then Echostar will have to stand by until May debt due and repeat the process.
#4 Is where it gets FUN. If Mel is the Mel that Wall street thinks he is, and happens to take care of the February and May debt all at once then ECHOSTAR will have to convert the debt it purchased into equity sending the stock to 52 week highs instantly. So in retrospect Ecostar could get paid the conventional way by simple appreciation of the stock price.
Now, Again I must warn that in my opinion, It is exactaly the #4 scenario that Mel was thinking of when he said " the Shorts will get Screwed along the way if they bet against us"
Not a fact (YET) just a warning!
>>>It's a highly risky way to take control and could easily backfire... remember Echo has $300M at stake.
Well not quite $300 million, but likely over $200 million. And it is risky, given their holdings would be junior to the bank debt, as noted.
My guess is that Sirius was trying to convince ECHO to a equity for debt swap on the remaining amounts of the Feb09 that they hold -- and ECHO was demanding too much... like a new senior convertible or to exchange it for preferred shares or something like that... and will not take the common, that Sirius likely offered them. That's probably what this is all about. Sirius still has the ability to just use cash - but that would certainly put Sirius in a tough position going through 2009, unless they can finally put together a new term loan, as they indicated they were interested in doing.
As for the Dec09 amounts -- obviously ECHO didn't pay face value for them, so they got that $200+ million at a deep discount. Sirius will have their work cut out for them to refinance that debt later this year. Even if Sirius clears the Feb and May hurdles -- I would not be surprised to see that the overhang from ECHO and these Dec09 bonds will hit the pps hard all year.
PS - As I suspected this afternoon -- ECHO had no purchases of the May09 bank debt. JPM and UBS have too much at stake with those holdings to just sell them to ECHO.