SiriusXM Answers Back In Howard Stern Intern Lawsuit

fruit saladSiriusXM has wasted very little time in firing back on a potential class action lawsuit involving a former intern for the Howard Stern Show.  The suit alleges that SiriusXM failed to pay a non-paid intern and according to the plaintiff, Melissa Tierney was born from an alleged injury suffered when getting Stern his fruit salad.  At this point, with all due respect to the parties involved, I have dubbed the suit as, “The Fruit Salad Suit“.

SirusXM has issued a detailed response that outlines 75 specific responses and 14 specific defenses in this action.  Defenses include:

  • Plaintiff and any opt-ins or individuals whom Plaintiff seeks to represent have failed, in whole or in part, to state claims upon which relief can be granted.
  • Plaintiff’s claims and the claims of any opt-ins or individuals whom Plaintiff seeks to represent are barred, in whole or in part, by statutory exemptions, exclusions, exceptions, or credits under the FLSA and New York Labor Law, including, but not limited to, the intern and/or trainee exceptions to the FLSA and New York Labor Law.
  • Sirius acted in good faith and had reasonable grounds for believing that it was in compliance with the FLSA and New York Labor Law in its pay and classification practices with respect to Plaintiff and any opt-ins or individuals whom Plaintiff seeks to represent.
  • Plaintiff’s claims and the claims of any opt-ins or individuals whom Plaintiff seeks to represent are barred, in whole or in part, by the applicable statutes of limitations.
  • Plaintiff is not entitled to conditional or final certification or to Court-facilitated notice under 29 U.S.C. § 216(b) because Plaintiff is not similarly situated to potential opt-ins and Plaintiff cannot adequately represent the interests of the potential opt-ins.
  • Plaintiff’s attempt to bring her claims on behalf of a class as a class or collective action fails because an independent and individual analysis of the claims of Plaintiff and each individual whom she seeks to represent, and each of Sirius’ defenses, is required
  • Plaintiff is not entitled to class action certification under Rule 23 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure because Plaintiff cannot satisfy the requirements for bringing a class action and Plaintiff cannot adequately represent the interests of potential class members.
  • Adjudication of this case as a class or collective action would violate Sirius’ constitutional rights to due process.
  • To the extent that they are superseded or preempted by the FLSA, Plaintiff’s state law claims and the state law claims of opt-ins or individuals whom she seeks to represent are barred.
  • The claims of Plaintiff and any opt-ins or individuals whom she seeks to represent are barred, in whole or in part, by the doctrines of waiver, laches, estoppel, off-set, unclean hands, payment, lack of standing, and release.
  • Plaintiff’s claims and the claims of any opt-ins or individuals whom she seeks to represent are barred, in whole or in part, because they failed to demand payment.
  • Liquidated damages are not available because Sirius made a good faith and reasonable effort to comply with FLSA and the New York Labor Law and had reasonable grounds to believe that it had not violated the laws.
  • The time for which Plaintiff and opt-ins or the individuals she seeks to represent seek compensation does not, in whole or in part, constitute compensable working time.
  • Plaintiff and any opt-ins or individuals she seeks to represent are not employees as defined by the FLSA or New York Labor Law.

WHEREFORE, Sirius requests entry of judgment in its favor on the Complaint and prays that this Court:

(a) Dismiss the Complaint with prejudice;

(b) Award its costs and disbursements in this action, including attorneys’ fees; and

(c) Award Sirius such other and further relief as is just and proper. Sirius reserves the right to amend this Answer and Defenses to Plaintiff’s Complaint and add additional defenses as discovery may warrant.

Continue Reading »

howard-stern-hands-up

Howard Stern Intern Files Class Action Lawsuit Against Sirius XM

As if the Howard Stern Show were not already controversial enough, we now have a class action lawsuit from a Stern Intern for unpaid wages.  Plaintif  Melissa Tierney is suing SuirusXM for unpaid wages.  The suit is filed on behalf of herself and any similarly situated intern at SiriusXM.  The case centers around the fact… → Read More

howard-stern-jerry-seinfeld-car

Howard Stern Rides in a Car and has Coffee with Jerry Seinfeld

In his third season of Comedians In Cars Getting Coffee, Jerry Seinfeld finally takes a ride with Howard Stern where the two talk about their Daddy issues, bathroom habits, the cost of groceries, and what makes them tic. If you haven’t heard about Seinfeld’s new series, it’s exactly what it sounds like — a couple… → Read More

Howard-Stern-Birthday

Howard Stern’s Birthday Bash Special is FREE For Everyone Worldwide

Howard Stern and SiriusXM invite you, wherever you are in the world, to listen to Howard Stern’s Birthday Bash special for free, starting today at 4pm ET. The show will kick off with a two hour pre show red carpet event full of interviews, followed by the main even hosted by Jimmy Kimmel starting at… → Read More

johnny-orris-get-grandpa-laid-howard-stern

Howard Stern’s Get Grandpa Laid Winner Dies – Before Claiming Prize!

Ugh, So Close! The 86 year old Stern Show favorite, Johnny Orris has reportedly died before getting to claim his prize. Just hours before Grandpa Johnny was set to take a run at couple of prostitutes at the Bunny Ranch he was out celebrating with his loving grandson and choked on a bite of his… → Read More

scott-ferrall.jpg

Ferrall To Leave SiriusXM For Terrestrial Radio

Longtime Howard Stern channel sports host Scott Ferrall will be leaving satellite radio and headed to a Terrestrial radio deal with CBS Radio.  The new show, Ferrall On The Bench will be available on over 50 affiliate stations and will air from 10 PM to 2 AM beginning January 2, 2013.  Ferrall has been with… → Read More

Howard Stern Files Appeal in Lawsuit

It certainly did not take long for attorney’s from the Stern camp to get the paperwork together to file an appeal.  The original lawsuit was dismissed with prejudice and was first reported here at SiriusBuzz.   following the decision by Juge Barbara Kapnick, Howard Stern expressed dismay at the judges ruling and vowed an appeal. Following… → Read More

howard-stern-black-suit

A Deeper Look at the Howard Stern Lawsuit

As was reported here on SiriusBuzz, Sirius XM (NASDAQ:SIRI) has scored a victory in the lawsuit filed by Howard Stern in the form of a summary judgment with prejudice issued by Judge Barbara Kapnick.  A dismissal with prejudice does not preclude Stern from appealing the decision, and Stern has vowed to do just that.  Anything… → Read More

Howard Stern Joins America’s Got Talent – Rumored $15 Million Deal

Sirius XM morning personality Howard Stern will be the new judge on TV show “America’s Got Talent”.  The announcement this morning came from NBC, which Stern has had many issues with in the past, including a firing over 25 years ago from radio station WNBC.  Howard, which many view as controversial, will replace Piers Morgan… → Read More

quivers

Robin Quivers Gets Her Own Show – “The Chatter” On Howard 101

Some think it should have happened long ago while others feel that Robin Quivers getting her own show is an outrage.  That is the beauty of the Howard Stern channels.  They are full of opinionated debate and loyal listeners which, whether they support the new show or not, will certainly tune in.  Some will listen… → Read More